Bridges Across the Black
Carthage -
West Carthage
In the years 1808-06,
New
York
State cut through a right of way from
Utica and Rome to Lyons Falls (then High Falls) along the Black River to Long Falls, Town of Champion, and from there to Oswegatchie, now Ogdensburg and on
to Russell.
The Turnpike Company
constructed the St. Lawrence Turnpike in 1812-13; by adding another avenue to
northern settlements, made a bridge necessary to cross the
Black
River.
Russell Atwater and his associates, interested in St.
Lawrence settlements, were authorized by the Turnpike Company to build a toll
bridge over the Black
River where the state road
leading to Oswegatchie crosses the river – at the head of the
Long Falls in Champion.

Section of 1855
map
The bridge, to be completed by
November 1813, was planned and built for the Turnpike Company by
Ezra Church. When the
bridge was completed, the privilege of the first crossing was let and the
highest bidder was Elijah Fulton of West Carthage, who gave a gallon of rum for the privilege of driving
the first team across the bridge.
“There was high times while the rum
lasted.”
The toll bridge was maintained
until 1829. On March 28 of that
year the structure was found to be decayed, it was necessary to rebuild it. Early in the year an attempt was made to
secure by public subscription funds to build a free bridge. A meeting was called and the old piers
were purchased for $500.
About the same time, those
interested in factories on islands in the lower part of the village (the most
active being Joseph C. Budd) started a project to construct a bridge connecting
the islands. Mr. LeRay came to the
assistance and five bridges, going from island to island, secured a
crossing. The bridges were damaged
by the flood of the next spring, but were repaired. More damage was inflicted the following
spring, and the structures soon fell into decay.

There were
later island bridges – this one goes to Coburn
Island from the
W. Carthage
shore.
Meanwhile, those working for a
free bridge above the islands gained influence and money. Dr. Eli West championed the cause and in
the summer of 1829 the crossing was affected at a cost of $1,600. That bridge, built by H. G. Potter,
lasted 11 years.
When, in 1840, it was deemed
necessary to rebuild the bridge, a meeting of the Towns of Wilna and Champion
was called. The outcome was an act
passed in May authorizing loans from school funds- $2,500, Town of
Champion; $2,999, Wilna; $750, LeRay and $750, Pamelia – for
bridges in their areas, including Carthage-West Carthage.

With those funds, a man named
Spaulding, at a cost of $5,000, constructed a covered bridge. It lasted until 1853 when a “substantial
bridge was built by the State”. In
October of 1860 this bridge broke down under the weight of a large herd of
cattle. Some of them went down with
the broken span and were killed or injured.
On the morning of Tuesday of
last week a drove of cattle passed through our village, and while attempting to
cross the bridge, over the Black
River, the first span of the
bridge gave way, and about fifty head of cattle were precipitated into the
river. A large number had passed
the first span before it fell, and these running furiously over the remaining
portion of the bridge, the last span adjoining the Champion side of the river
also gave way and fell, with some fifteen or twenty head of cattle. We learned that two of the cattle were
so badly injured that they had to be immediately slaughtered. …
During that {next} day the sidewalk bridge was made passable and it is
expected that by Saturday next the bridge will be again passable for
teams.
CRT Oct 18, 1860
The bridge was repaired, but
one year later a Mr. Crumb, a well-known teamster, broke through the bridge
while crossing with a load of pig iron.
The iron slid out of the box and the horses swam ashore with the wagon
while the box floated downstream and lodged against one of the islands.
Mr. Crumb was rescued
unharmed.
On Wednesday last, two
stretches of the bridge over the Black River at Carthage broke, and two teams
which were then on the bridge, were precipitated into the river, and Mr. Samuel
Chadwick, about thirty-five years old, and a boy about ten years old, named
Henry Irwin, son of James Irwin, both of this village, lost their
lives. CRT April 4,
1865

On June 13,
1865 the Republican reported
that {State} Commissioner Skinner had taken charge of the bridge and had sent an
engineer and contractor to check out the bridge. Although made temporarily safe by H.
Rulison, a decision was made to erect a new “iron chord bridge” as soon as the
materials could be procured.

On September 26,
1865, The
Republican indicated that work was progressing on the new iron bridge,
with engineer O. L. Wetmore of Booneville supervising construction. Early in October, while placing
two of the arches on the new iron bridge the arches with the old timbers for one
span fell into the river and Moses LaRock was “considerably injured in his hands
and limbs, by falling into the river at the time of the accident.” On November 14 the newspaper reported
that the “fine structure is now complete.
It is 458 feet long with seven spans of arches. It was built by Messers. Britton & Co., of Cleveland, Ohio. It is a
Patent Tubular Arch Wrought Iron Bridge … of which there are 90 bridges of this style now in
use.” The paper went on to say
there had been a party at Morgan’s Hotel in honor of the contractor and the
successful completion of the work.

This is the bridge depicted in the sketch
of the Carthage Fire of 1884.

In
1872 the railroad was extended into Carthage and a railroad bridge was built at the time. According to the Republican
Tribune for March 14, 1873,
“the freight train on the
Utica and Black River Railroad which left
Watertown yesterday
morning met with a serious accident just
before entering the covered bridge this side of
Carthage. Three
cars jumped the track and fell into the river. One of the cars was loaded with potatoes
owned by John Winslow Jr. {of Carthage}. The
covered bridge was seriously damaged and the track was torn up the length of the
bridge. About a week will be
required to repair the damage. No
injuries were reported although the flagman, John H. Wheeler did sustain a minor
cut to his forehead.” (Reprinted RT March 15, 1973)

In
1896 New
York
State built the Twin Villages’ fifth bridge, wider and
stronger, but by 1942 that bridge was in need of replacement; increased traffic
and the additional weight of that traffic had caused much wear and tear on the
existing structure.
In April of that year there was an article in the
CRT that the idea of constructing the new Carthage-West Carthage bridge might have to be put on hold in deference to a state
road from the Deer River Corners in W. Carthage to Great Bend and Pine Camp.
It was stated that the new road would give Pine Camp a straight road
south and would fit in with the “new” Deferiet-Fargo road that gave the camp
direct access to the north route.
In this way, Pine Camp would become a traffic center with direct routes
from that point rather than from Carthage or Watertown.

The next
bridge was finished in 1948 at a cost of $135,000 authorized by the state
legislature. Interesting
information in the November 1947 CRT describes moving the old state
bridge fifty feet upstream onto temporary piers while the new span was being
completed. The moving was completed
on a Friday morning when Hawes and Farrell, Inc of Oneida whose engineers were
in charge of the project, stated “vehicular traffic on Route 26 will open early
next week to light traffic although the detour {via Great Bend} will be
maintained until the new bridge is completed”. It was further reported that W. Carthage
deliveries presented a serious problem for most firms and that this was further
complicated by construction on Route 3 near Great Bend and the closing the first
week in November of the Castorland-Naumburg bridges to heavy loads.

The Tuscarora Construction Co,
Inc of Pulaski built the next bridge over a period of 18 months, in
1994-95. It was done on contract
with the New York DOT at a bid price of $4,059,689.75

Great Bend
A bridge was constructed on
“the bend” of the Black
River in 1804, the first in
Jefferson County. In 1807 a
Mr. Tubbs built a dam and gristmill for Olney Pierce and Egbert TenEych above the bridge. Later that year both structures
burned. A large crowd of people
gathered on the bridge to watch when the river seized the ruins of the mill and
dam and sent them downstream where they destroyed the bridge. Some spectators were still on the
bridge; two boys were thrown into river where one was drowned. In 1840 most of the business section was
burned along with the covered bridge.

In 1862 floods again destroy
the bridge along with drowning a boy who was on it. [Unsure whether this boy was actually
the victim of the 1807 disaster or another child – records aren’t clear].

Deferiet
Bridge

Early picture of
Deferiet Bridge
In late
September of 1964, the bridge over the Black River and linking Route 3 with the
village of Deferiet was severely damaged by a 21-ton bulldozer being
transported across on a flatbed truck.
The dozer blade had sheared three girders making the bridge unsafe for
heavy traffic. One lane was open to
local traffic, but the buses of the Carthage Central School had to be rerouted for a bout a week. The Deferiet Elementary students that
normally received a hot lunch at Great Bend had a ride of nearly a half hour each way instead of
the normal five minutes. It
required seven pieces of steel 50 feet long and 2600 pounds were used in the
repair work.

The bridge in Deferiet has been replaced
several times. This picture from
the August 27, 1986 CRT shows the new bridge under construction. The old bridge, on the left, was still
in use. New cement work is seen in
the foreground.

The view below shows the work
site from the Great
Bend side. This shot was taken on a Sunday as the
work went on to finish the project.

Black River
In 1950 the Watertown Daily
Times ran this picture along with an article that stated this bridge, built
in 1896 would be dismantled to make way for a new bridge that would cost an
estimated $100,000. The new
bridge, which had a steel floor roadway 24 feet wide (10 feet wider than the one
pictured below) was also 18 feet longer.

The bridge was opened to
traffic on Friday July 27, 1951.
According to the WDT, the first person to cross the bridge after
its official opening was the man who directed its construction, Highway
Superintendent Walter R. Eggleston.
This bridge was replaced in 2005.

Section of 1888
panorama
******************************************************
Information obtained from
articles by Helen B Walker in the March
24, 1976 CRT, the April 10 1941 CRT, August 27, 1986 CRT, July 27,
1951 WDT, Sidewalks and Oysters by R.
Joseph Giblin (1991), Old North Country Bridges, Richard
Sanders Allen (1983) and other sources.